SKIP TO CONTENT
BESTCREATES.
★ 0
HEAD TO HEAD
Beehiiv
9.0 / 10
vs
Substack
7.9 / 10
THE VERDICT
Winner: Beehiiv.

The honest answer: it depends on what you're building.

Substack is a magazine masquerading as software. The recommendation engine grows new writers faster than any other platform on earth, and the Notes feed gives you a built-in audience to talk to. The trade-off is you don't fully own the relationship and you pay 10% on every paid sub forever.

Beehiiv is software that respects you're building a business. Boosts let you buy growth at a known CAC. The ad network turns idle list size into revenue. Custom domain on cheap tiers, real segmentation, an editor that's catching up fast.

If you're finding your voice: Substack. If you've found it and you want to build a media company: Beehiiv.

Beehiiv
The newsletter platform built by people who actually ran one.
PROS
  • +Boosts are a real growth lever
  • +Built-in monetization (ads + premium)
  • +Analytics that don't require a spreadsheet
CONS
  • −Editor still trails Substack in feel
  • −Boosts cost real money
Substack
Distribution dressed as a publishing platform.
PROS
  • +Recommendations engine is unreasonably good
  • +Writer-friendly editor
  • +Notes and comments build community
CONS
  • −You don't fully own the audience
  • −10% take on paid subscriptions stings
// THE BRIEF

THE BEST
CREATES BRIEF.

ONE EMAIL PER WEEK. THE TOOLS THAT MATTER. NO ROUNDUPS OF "TOP 47 AI TOOLS".